Tuesday 18 September 2012

Difference between PLC,DCS & SCADA

                   In the past the strength and weakness of both the automation technologies were well understood. So it was easy for engineers to select the one that suits their application, but now due to the advent of microprocessors both the technologies are merging.The requirements which are thought to be exclusive to one technology can be found in the other one too.But still there are some things which are to be checked out before selecting the one that suits your application the best.

Now a days you cannot really tell the difference between a PLC or a DCS. Since the PLC was integrated with Analog I/O it crosses the boundary of being just digital and crosses to the realm of DCS in handling Analogs, Bus Systems, Distributed I/O and etc. Also, since the DCS now handles logics of Digital I/O it also crossed the boundary to the realm of PLC.

As you know PLC as to its name Programmable Logic Controller. Its main purpose is to replace the relay logic controls which is "On" or "Off". And DCS "Distributed Control Systems" its emphasis is Fast analog handling because of communications through Bus systems, networking and etc.

Summarizing all these, PLC = DCS......BUT still there are basic differences as below

PLC is a programmable Logic controller which is used mainly for interlocking different equipments.PLC using for perticular mechine or production unit.PLC is economicaly low cost.PLC'S can handle analog and digital I/O as earliear it could handle only digital.PLC'S are automatic controllers which is a substitute to hard wired controllers.they are extensively used for automation.PLC is for stand alone sytem.PLC is used Commonly with On\Off (Digital) Control and may be expanded with Analog I\O Modules for Analog Control and used for a control task.
                                      Programmable Logic Controller



DCS: DISTRIBUTED CONTROL SYSTEMS: THIS SYSTEM DOES WHAT A
PLC WOULD DO, BUT THE DIFFERENCE IS THAT A DCS IS USED IN
MUCH LARGER AND COMPLEX APPLICATION E.G: POWER GENERATION,
SOME COLD ROLLING MILLS etc.


DCS is the System in which controller are distributed geographically and integrated all the control hardwares .which is connected from the various field devices .DCS having its own network, Controller and HMI etc….Honeywell, Yokogawa, Invensys, ABB, Emerson are the leading .DCS Vendors.DCS is the System in which controller are distributed geographically and integrated all the control hardwares which is connected from the various field devices.DCS having its own network, Controller and HMI etc…Honeywell, Yokogawa, Invensys, ABB, Emerson are the leading DCS Vendors 

                                           Distributed  Controller System
                       If taken from a narrow point of view, maybe PLC and DCS are functionally the same. However, a lot of plant technicians and engineers are not aware of the other side of the debate, namely the engineering effort and the commercial ramifications. Of course, for huge plants with I/O's ranging from 10,000 to 30,000 I/O points, and beyond, it is silly to even think about PLC. From my experience, a DCS is not the same with PLC in the realm of huge systems such as oil and gas plants, as the following list will show:

1. A PLC is cost-effective up to a certain I/O count, and so is the DCS. But the difference is in their starting points: the PLC is cost-effective from 0 to a few thousand I/O points; the DCS becomes cost-effective starting from a few thousand points and beyond. 

2. A PLC becomes a subsystem of the DCS in rare occasions when the situation calls for it, i.e., purchase of huge package systems with engineering schedules incompatible with the DCS schedule (I/O lists cannot be submitted on time before the DCS hardware freeze date). Note that this package system is a process system using continuous control, not discrete. Based on this, a PLC can never be larger than a DCS in terms of I/O count.

3. In large plants the DCS is king because most owners want a single source of hardware support and service, and this mentality naturally denies the PLC a foothold. Package vendors are no longer required to provide PLC for their system. Everything is connected to the DCS.


SCADA: AS ALREADY EXPLAINED, IT NOTHING BUT A SOFTWARE USED 
TO GATHER DATA FROM THE FIELDS INSTRUMENTS WITH THE HELP OF
YOUR DCS OR PLC DEPENDING ON THE APPLICATION VIA THE SERVER
AND MAKING IT AVAILABLE IN AN ANIMATED FORM. THIS IS
USUALLY FOUND IN YOUR CONTROL ROOMS AND DEVELOPMENT ROOM


                                                                            SCADA
SCADA is the Software tool in which you can able to view/Monitor/Control your Process Variable data and Graphical representation of your plant etc...It's an operator front end display Example of few SCADA S/W is Wonderware, IFix, RS View, WinCC etc
SCADA is Supervisory Control and Data Aquisition which is used to control and Monitor small number of Equipments in a field.SCADA systems are typically used to perform data collection and control at the supervisory level. Some systems are called SCADA despite only performing data acquisition and not control.The supervisory control system is a system that is placed on top of a real-time control system to control a process that is external to the 

SCADA system (i.e. a computer, by itself, is not a SCADA system even though it controls its own power consumption and cooling). This implies that the system is not critical to control the process in real time, as there is a separate or integrated real-time automated control system that can respond quickly enough to compensate for process changes within the time constants of the process 

SCADA is the Software tool in which you can able to
view/Monitor/Control your Process Variable data and
Graphical representation of your plant etc...
It's an operator front end display
Example of few SCADA S/W is Wonderware, IFix, RS View,
WinCC etc 


IN SHORT!

PLC:

  • in manufacturing processes(for production of things)
  • for simple batch control 
  • intensive logic controls
  • can handle a no. of I/O s at a time
  • downtime => lost production
  • usually,no need of redundancy 
  • fast logic scan(=reading I/Ps executing instructions and providing O/Ps)
  • compact
  • easily customised 
  • for smaller applications

DCS:
  • in process control (for production of stuff) 
  • for complex batch control
  • advanced analog loop controls
  • downtime=>lost production+damage to process equipment+ may lead to dangerous conditions
  • so Redundancy must
  • large in size
  • cant be easily customised
  • for larger applications and plant-wide
In detail

What are you manufacturing??

PLC:for simple batch control i.e.,manufacturing a batch of goods(things)
Eg.,in bottling plants
DCS:for complex batch process i.e.,producing a product by transmission from raw materials(producing stuff)
Eg.,in oil refining plants,in steel making 
Specific to type of control
PLC: very logic control intensive.Can handle a no. of digital and analog I/O's at a time.
DCS: Regulatory/Analog loop control.It also provides ratio/cascade/model-predictive /feed forward control

Effect of downtime
What is downtime?

It is the time that the process takes to come to normal operation after a catastrophic failure.
PLC: Downtime results in only lost production and does not typically damage the process conditions or equipment.
For eg.,if there is some problem in the manufacturing process of a bottling plant, even if the process is stopped for a while, resuming the process back to its normal operation is simple and not time tacking. providing redundancy will be costlier than handling the downtime expenses so generally redundancy is not provided by this.
DCS: Downtime results not only in lost production but also leads to dangerous conditions or damages the process line and resuming the process is expensive and difficult too.
For eg.,In steel making process if the process stops abruptly and the pipelines with process fluid contents may freeze and damage the pipelines this would lead to more expenses.

Degree of customisation
PLC:It delivers a tool-kit of functions and building blocks that can be easily customized.So it can be used for varied applications by programming it according to the application.
DCS: Its highest priority is high reliability so standard functions are baked in to provide a complete solution to a particular application. So it can't accept many custom modifications.

Up-front cost
PLC: in $$
DCS: in $$$$ ;However its superior to PLC in operation and proprietary in general.
Size
PLC: compact
DCS: large
Replacement
PLC: replaced the conventional relays
DCS: replaced the pneumatic & single loop controllers


DCS is Distributed Control Systems which is used to control very big plants by using simple GUI screens.PLCs are interfaced with DCS for interlocking.

35 comments:

  1. Good Amount of Information about PLC, DCS and SCADA..
    Thankyou..!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Nice information for industrial automation..,

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice Blog telling us the differences between PLC and SCADA.
    Click here for more information on PLC and SCADA Training

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very informative. kindly share your contact address. I am working on a research project on PLC, DCS & SCADA. Need your expertise

    ReplyDelete
  5. For gonna do PLC SCADA DCS and Industrial Automation training in India, You can visit here for Free Online Live Chat @ http://www.plctraininginchennai.net

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good information on different controlling systms used in industries.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Such a nice and useful post, but An important element of making an industrial organization more efficient is managing energy consumption. A great way to do this is to use Real-time power measurement monitors the amount of electricity consumed by a residence, business, or an electrical device. If any wants to get more info please visit: http://www.intellisyssoftware.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. You can follow the step by step guide to download LearnersTV video. The guide can also work to download video from YouTube, Vimeo, Facebook, etc at
    http://www.allavsoft.com/how-to/download-learnerstv-videos.html

    ReplyDelete
  10. I do suggest Noida is the Best place to start your career in the field of Industrial Automation , PLC SCADA Training in Noida, MATLAB by undergoing Hands-on Project Training at Croma campus any query call now +91-7503121768

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks

    http://www.plc-scada-dcs.blogspot.com/p/delta-plc-tutorials.html

    ReplyDelete
  12. DIAC launches a 100% Placement Oriented PLC Automation Training program which can provide you technical & soft skill upgrade with placement. Call @9310096831.

    ReplyDelete
  13. hi friends,thank you for your information. i need help here at scada line got freeze and after change modem its become normal in 2 hours . freeze back. freeze at (acid to alkaline). any solution? is it becouse of modem internet becouse im using 100base only

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey Friends....
    DIAC offering 2 months industrial training with placement and also gives participation certificate. Actually it’s automation, how machine works automatically in industries and it’s about ME, ECE, EEE, EE, IC.
    Interested students call at 91-9310096830/31 and register yourself for training.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Great post. Thank you for sharing such useful information. Please keep sharing
    PLC SCADA training in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  16. DIAC: Best industrial automation training institute in noida, delhi ncr. Affordable course fees, 100% job guarantee in industrial automation, free demo sessions and study material. Call @9310096831.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This post is really good and informative. The explanation given is really comprehensive.

    PLC SCADA Training


    ReplyDelete
  18. DIAC the best PLC, SCADA, HMI, Drives, Automation summer training institute offers 6 months Industrial training with blend of theory and practical sessions. Call us : 91- 9953489987.

    ReplyDelete
  19. PLC SCADA 4/6 Weeks Summer Industrial Training  | Best PLC SCADA Industrial Training in Delhi- 9818293887
    The best PLC SCADA summer training company in Noida due to facilitating students with affordable course fee, placement solution and world-class practical summer training to the participants. Call @9953489987.

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.

    CEH Training In Hyderbad

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thank you for sharing such great information very useful to us.
    PLC SCADA Training in Noida

    ReplyDelete
  23. Are you looking for best Industrial Automation Courses. DIAC Institute providing hands on Practical Training in Advanced Industrial Automation with Technical Lab Facilities and 100% Job in core company. Call @91-9953489987.

    ReplyDelete
  24. DIAC Training Institute providing 6 months training in industrial Automation(
    PLC, SCADA, HML, DRIVES, PANEL DESIGNING, PROCESS INSTRUMENTION ,INDUSTRIAL NETWORKING, MOTOR DRIVE,CNG COMPRESSOR,TRAINING)
    today our special offer for free demo class. For more details call @ +91-9953489987, +91-9711287737.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Awesome post. You Post is very informative. Thanks for Sharing.
    SCADA Training in Noida

    ReplyDelete
  26. The Sites are filled with Full of Encouraging and Enhancing Stuffs... You Post is very informative...Thanks for this Kind work
    Java training in chennai | Java training in annanagar | Java training in omr | Java training in porur | Java training in tambaram | Java training in velachery

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thanks For sharing Your information The Information Shared Is Very Valuable Please Keep updating Us Time Just Went On Reading The Article..Thanks for sharing your informative post on development.
    Salesforce Training in Chennai

    Salesforce Online Training in Chennai

    Salesforce Training in Bangalore

    Salesforce Training in Hyderabad

    Salesforce training in ameerpet

    Salesforce Training in Pune

    Salesforce Online Training

    Salesforce Training

    ReplyDelete
  28. I like you post. It is very useful to all.
    In this post having more useful information and improve our knowledge. Can you share more valuable information present Technology.

    Power Bi Training in GUrgaon
    SQL Training in Gurgaon
    Advanced Excel /VBA training in Gurgaon
    Tableau Training in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks for the Valuable information.Really useful information. Thank you so much for sharing. It will help everyone.

    GRAPHIC DESIGN TRAINING IN DELHI

    FOR MORE INFO:

    ReplyDelete
  30. DIAC offers training for corporate sector employees with courses like PLC, SCADA, VFD, DCS, AUTOCAD, ROBOTICS , and many other Industrial Automation Courses.
    For detail, you can directly contact @ 9953489987
    You can visit our website: www.diac.co.in

    ReplyDelete
  31. PIX Garden / Lawn Mower Belts are expertly produced and developed using the highest standard technologies and materials to meet the toughest demands.
    It is thanks to the unrivaled reliability of these belts that PIX garden belts are one of the most respected brands in the lawn and garden belt industry. The PIX range of garden belts / lawn mower belts includes the following types of belts:
    1. PIX-LawnMaster® - wrapped belts, belts for mowers
    2. PIX-Enforcer®-XS - wrapped belts two-way foldable, high power, high strength
    3. PIX-Duo®-XS - Double-sided wrapped belts , hexagonal
    Courroies Tondeuses

    ReplyDelete
  32. NRSKitchen is a trusted leader in commercial kitchen equipment manufacturers in Delhi. NRSKitchen is ever-ready with a wide range of solutions that every client can depend on. We offer Restaurant Equipment dealers in Delhi. NRSKitchen features a wide range of products from reputed national and international brands – at guaranteed low prices.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. You can visit my website Link. Zonder gas wonen in netherlands

    ReplyDelete